KOA Solves Bot Problem Forever!

[Darth Kaz2]

Wouldn't that be a geat headline to see on Jagex/RS Homepage! Let's do it...lets work out the perfect solution to the bot problem and present it to Jagex. I am opening up this thread to discussion on this topic. Feel free to offer solutions and pick holes in one another's ideas. There just has to be a workable solution to botting! (doesn't there?)

The 'Darth Proposal' is as follows:
I submit that the primary solution to doing away with bots is to allow players to 'do away with' bots. We the players are the largest part of the game. If there is a method by which we can kill bots as we see them, the bot problem can be minimized or solved.

Just imagine, the ability to kill auto advertisers at the ge, or gold miners in lrc! It would make training at the worst bot locations the most fun! For the botters, everywhere would be open season on bots, like Green Dragons in the wildy.

The question, of course, is logistics. How do we allow bot hunting everywhere, without turning the entire world into the WILDY? (A horrid thought!)

I am proposing a method of challenging other players. This challenge could be issued anywhere (except maybe banks or other secure locations). If the challenge goes unanswered for a certain period of time (maybe 5 minutes), then the challenger would be free to attack you. Upon death, a challenged player would drop their inventory and respawn after a delay (I am thinking 15 minutes). A person could only be challenged once every hour or so, to minimize annoying spamming.

Would this work? What am I missing?

Come on KOA, let's save Jagex and RS together! We can demand free lifetime memberships or something as a reward!! :lol:

[DoctorDRAG0N]

What a misleading topic title! LOL, I saw the headline & was like "What? =D OMG OMG OMG! YESSS!"
LOL. Interesting proposal. A step in any direction, at this point, is a step in the right direction.

[Dr Brad]

Some discussion of this already here:

http://www.koaclan.co.uk/forums/viewtopi ... =59&t=7067

[Tamal]

Two weeks later bot scripts are updated to handle challenges

I, for one, think that all mouse and keyboard movement/input should be fed back to Jagex for analysis. It's extremely hard to fake human randomness (as opposed to computer-generated randomness).

EDIT: Also, dynamically generated item IDs per build or per session.

[Diplomatt]

It's extremely hard to fake human randomness .

Trust me, my clicks are very random at times, including my cc chat!

[Satrianisaxe]

Have agree with Tamal. I liken "Bot-makers" to bacteria. As soon as we find a way of destroying they start to tweak and mutate themselves to become "resistant" to the "cure". (I know - I love bugs - they so much smarter than us). But good on you Darth for being pro-active in the fight!

[Dima]

Hiring 300 employees whose sole purpose is to scour the world for bots. Arr, pretty stupid but works like a charm.

[Darth Kaz2]

Tamal,
I am not familiar with the programming strategies/limitations of bot scripts. Does the variety of random events stall bot programs? Is there a way of randomizing the visual image of a player challenge that would defeat most bot programs?

[Tamal]

I'll admit that I don't know the nitty-gritty as well; but it is my understanding that the more recent bot engines don't rely on colors/images, but rather tap into the RuneScape Java applet itself and can identify objects onscreen by ID numbers:



Thus any sort of visual tricks just make the game harder for humans, but the bots have no problem.

[Dave]

Yep, that's what the "newer" bots use. I put quotations because they've been using it for a little while now. (AFAIK)

Its tough to stop them though...when they can bot seemingly random skills such as slayer or dungeoneering.

[Darth Kaz2]

Hmmm...Do botting programs type anything, or simply click on items on the screen? This is what I am thinking...
You see a player you suspect of being a bot...you click on 'Challenge Player' and type that character's name into the screen. Then the challenge pops up in the message section of the challenged players screen. The challenge shows your character name...they have about 2 minutes to click on the challenge and TYPE YOUR NAME in to refuse the challenge. They are then immune from challenges for a set period of time, maybe 30-60 minutes.

Would a botting program be able to mimic this?

[beefeater555]

Kill'em all is what I say, and I do everytime I get bored. I can get up to 400 dragon bones an hour killing bots. And there's the added bonus of fighting greedy bot killers too.

Humm... I might have to make this an event. The KoA way of solving the bot problem!

[DoctorDRAG0N]

Kill'em all is what I say, and I do everytime I get bored. I can get up to 400 dragon bones an hour killing bots. And there's the added bonus of fighting greedy bot killers too.

Humm... I might have to make this an event. The KoA way of solving the bot problem!

Sign me up! <):)

[scootch]

Have Always Said Bots Meet the Supply and demand Of Online Gaming. jagex has Been no differnt.the rare Tradable drops. We want this right now. Being Able to Buy are Levels.Bots pay for the game like Honest Folk. Its revenue For runescape.Who is Now A Public Company. Who answers to stock holders.
As Adults No Further Explination On that.

Personally I am Sick of Bots. they are everywhere In runescape. I figure whats the Point. What ever Jagex does It Wont go away.

Taking A Hardline. Make it all Untradable. Is the Only way to Get rid Of the Blight this game
IMO

[Gridenough]

One thing you are missing is that sometimes real players turn off the conversation thing. I have done so when fishing amongst people with really boring or profane conversation. Sometimes I also turn it off if I want to have more screen clickable. maybe just make a challenge something that would pierce this.