Help Design KoA's Motif Part I

[Tamal]

Help Design KoA's Motif
Part I

Greetings fellow KoAers,

It is time to help design KoA's official clan motif:

Color: Dark blue with white trim (Asgarnian colors)
Design #1: Star image as-close-as-we-can-get-to-Asgarnia's-star (Saradomin symbol, prayer symbol, or quest symbol)
Design #2: It's up for a clan vote!

All of the available icons are listed in batches below. Post a reply in this thread with your favorite choice. Next week we'll gather the top nominations and put forth a poll in Help Design KoA's Motif Part II.

When making your selection, try to refer to it by batch and column/row. E.g., the icon used in the motif above is Batch 8, Row 1, Column 3 (Skull with crown):




Batch 1


Batch 2


Batch 3


Batch 4


Batch 5


Batch 6


Batch 7


Batch 8

[Dave]

If I was to choose I'd go with either Batch 1 Row 1 Column 3 (castle)

or Batch 2 Row 1 Column 5 (A)

[godoffire420]

+ 1 with that

[rilo carlile]

I would go with ...

Batch 1 Row 1 Column 3, Batch 2 Row 1 Column 4 ... these two. Like so:



Seeing as how we're a Kingdom, a castle is a nice icon for it, the second one just goes with the design nicely and it looks cool to me

EDIT: the A looks good too though, here's the other suggestion made so far, graphically:

[SnowAngel]

I like batch 8, column2 better for the star

Batch 4, row 2, column 2 because it shows that KoA is about having fun.

I also like Batch 8, row 1, column 3

[Sir Chris]

Design #1: Star image as-close-as-we-can-get-to-Asgarnia's-star (Saradomin symbol, prayer symbol, or quest symbol)
I know this is not what you were asking for but I think batch 8 #2 is the closest(quest?), more so than prayer or sara

Design #2: It's up for a clan vote!
I'm torn between
5-3-2 (the sheild)
8-1-3 (skull/crown)
1-1-3 (castle)

but if i HAD to chose just one.....I think I'd go

8-1-3 Skull/crown

[rilo carlile]

I hate the skull, it makes us seem like a pk'er clan, which I don't think many of us identify with.

[onezerobin]

Batch 2, Row 1, Column 1

Capture1.JPG (8.84 KiB) Viewed 6710 times

and Batch 8, column 2

Capture2.JPG (8.53 KiB) Viewed 6710 times

[Dr Brad]

Is anyone concerned that if we use this design:

Capture2.JPG (8.53 KiB) Viewed 6703 times

we're sending a message that we're a questing clan? (shudders!) LOL

[Dr Brad]

I like the castle too. Looks like Falador castle (Asgarnia)

[SnowAngel]

I don't think it looks too much like a quest symbol. Tamal could see what it looks like on the actual cape and let us know though.

[Dvdrak]

Batch 2 row 1 column 5

or

Batch 1 row 1 column 3

[GrandmasterH]

im ganna call this...
Killers and Skillers

Killers and Skillers.jpg (4.84 KiB) Viewed 6686 times

[TrixStar]

Batch 7 the squirrel

/thread

[justbored60]

castle a symbol